CGP Helps Planners Know Their History

Where do charitable gift planners, fund raisers, trust officers, attorneys and financial advisors turn for knowledge of events that shape their work today? The National Association of Charitable Gift Planners (CGP) has made resources available at no charge.

In its Council Connections sent on July 24, CGP encouraged gift planning councils to show a free digital webinar at their meetings and conferences:

Free Webinar Opportunity

“CGP adds a new and unique webinar offering for councils. Planned giving historian Ron Brown has created a new webinar, America is a Given Place, and is providing presentations free of charge to interested councils.”

To read Council Connections see: https://mailchi.mp/charitablegiftplanners/juen-council-connections-5041065?e=85016abfbb

For more about America is a Given Place see: https://wp.me/pb878a-eQ

And on its website, CGP has added a substantial new historical narrative entitled “Charitable Gift Planning in America”: https://charitablegiftplanners.org/history  

Knowledge of history is the soundest foundation for planning for the future. Many thanks to Kent Weimer, CGP Board Chair and Michael Kenyon, CGP President and CEO, for helping gift planners learn how American gift planning arrived at where we are today.


More about America is a Given Place:

Brief preview clip: https://wp.me/pb878a-fH

Practical benefits from watching: https://wp.me/pb878a-gH

Praise for the webinar: https://wp.me/pb878a-fs

Ron Brown’s speaker bio and promotional piece for your website: https://wp.me/pb878a-gV

Summary outline of webinar topics: https://wp.me/pb878a-gf

Selected sources: https://wp.me/pb878a-go

Selected Sources for America is a Given Place

Charitable bequests by Mary Chilton Winslow and other Mayflower Pilgrims (1620-1679): Caleb Johnson’s Mayflower History.com, wills of Mayflower passengers at http://mayflowerhistory.com/probate-records

Rev. Thomas Bargrave bequest (1621): “Henrico and Its College” by Robert Hunt, The William and Mary Quarterly, Oct. 1938, Vol. 18, No. 4, pages 453- 498.

“John Harvard: Brief life of a Puritan philanthropist: 1607-1638” by Conrad Edick Wright in Harvard Magazine at https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2000/01/john-harvard.html.

Harvard College gifts of cash, bequests, annuities, land, buildings, and equipment (1636-1712): Margery Somers Foster, “Out of Smalle Beginings…”: An Economic History of Harvard College in the Puritan Period (Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press, 1962), pages 106-122.

Charitable bequests in the wills of George Washington (1799) and James Madison (1836): Wills of the U.S. Presidents, Herbert R. Collins and David B. Weaver (New York: Communications Channels Inc., 1976), pages 15-31 and 42-48.

Benjamin Franklin’s testamentary charitable trusts: “The Codicil of the Will of Benjamin Franklin (1789),” Dwight F. Burlingame, ed., Philanthropy in America: A Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia (Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO Inc, 2004), pages 589-591. Also “From Ben Franklin, a Gift That’s Worth Two Fights” by Fox Butterfield, New York Times, April 21, 1990.

James Logan’s testamentary charitable trusts (1751): https://librarycompany.org/2017/06/09/treasures-from-the-library-company-of-philadelphia-4/

Charitable trusts managed by the City of Philadelphia: http://www.citytrusts.com/

Statute of Charitable Uses (1601): David C. Hammack, Making the Nonprofit Sector in the United States: A Reader (Bloomington & Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1998), pages 3-8. The best history of charitable trusts is the wide-ranging collection of essays entitled Itinera Fiduciae: Trust and Treuhand in Historical Perspective, ed. by Richard Helmholz and Reinhard Zimmermann (Berlin: Duncker & Humblot, 1998). See also the extensively-documented essay “The 1000-Year History of Charitable Trusts” by Ronald Brown at https://giftplanninghistory.org/2019/09/01/the-1000-year-history-of-charitable-trusts/

U.S. Supreme Court decisions on charitable trusts: Trustees of Philadelphia Baptist Association v. Hart’s Executors (1819) and Vidal v. Girard’s Executors (1844). See George G. Bogert et al, Cases and Text on the Law of Trusts, 6th ed. (Westbury, NY: The Foundation Press, Inc., 1991), Chapter 10: “Charitable Trusts,” pages 200-238. Also Girard Will Case: Arguments of the Defendants’ Counsel and Judgment of the Supreme Court … To Which is Added the Will of Stephen Girard (Philadelphia: J. Crissy, Printer, 1844) and https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/archive/girard-college/

John Trumbull’s gift annuity with Yale College: see A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 13-81.

Peter Augustus Jay and professional collaboration: see A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 26-29 and 48-72.

Luther Bradish’s report “On the Matter of Accepting Trusts” (1848): full text published in A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 317-324.

Alfred Williams Anthony and the Committee on Financial and Fiduciary Matters: Linking Christian Education with Financial Agencies: What Has Been Done and What It Means, a Report for 1926 (New York: FCCCA, 1927). Cooperation in Fiduciary Service: Papers Presented at a Conference on Financial and Fiduciary Matters (New York: Abbott Press & Mortimer-Walling, 1927; Wise Public Giving Series, no. 14).

Gift annuity campaign of the American Bible Society (1919-1930): A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 110-121.

Planned giving advertising campaign by the Bank of New York and Trust Company and other firms (1926): Alfred Williams Anthony, Linking Christian Education with Financial Agencies: What Has Been Done and What It Means, a Report for 1926 (New York: FCCCA, 1927), A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 180-181. Also the webinar “The History of ACGA is the History of Gift Planning in America” by Ron Brown, ACGA Conference 2020.

First Conference on Gift Annuities, and founding of the American Council on Gift Annuities (1927): Annuity Agreements of Charitable Organizations: Papers, Findings and Conclusions of a Conference on Annuities (New York: Abbott Press and Mortimer-Walling, 1927; Wise Public Giving Series, no. 18) and A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 169-228.

George Augustus Huggins and the actuarial revolution in American philanthropy: “Actuarial Basis of Rates,” Annuity Agreements of Charitable Organizations: Papers, Findings and Conclusions of a Conference on Annuities (New York: Abbott Press and Mortimer-Walling, 1927; Wise Public Giving Series, no. 18) and A History of Charitable Gift Planning by Ronald Brown (Amazon: 2017), pages 169-228.

Cornell University gift planning (1924-1934): Harold Flack, “The Cornell University Bequest Program,” Philanthropy for the Future: A Long-Range Look at Economic Policies in the Field of Charity, ed. Alfred Williams Anthony (New York: Committee on Financial and Fiduciary Matters, 1931), Wise Public Giving Series No. 36, pages 96-101.

Joint Conference of Colleges, Trust Institutions, Life Insurance and the Bar sponsored by the Association of American Colleges (1934): Bulletin of the Association of American Colleges, Vol. XX (May 1934), No. 2.

Stanford University R-Plan Manual for donors and professional advisors (1937)

Pomona College’s life-income gift plans (1944-1960): Norman S. Fink and Howard C. Metzler, The Costs and Benefits of Deferred Giving (New York: Columbia University Press, 1982), and “Pomona College Leads a Post-WWII Boom in Planned Giving,” Ronald Brown at https://giftplanninghistory.org/2019/09/01/pomona-college-leads-a-post-wwii-boom-in-planned-giving/

For a snapshot of the state of charitable gift planning in the 1940s see Jacob Kay Lasser, How Tax Laws Make Giving to Charity Easy (New York: Fund & Wagnalls Company, 1948. Sidney Prerau succeeded Lasser as head of the J.K. Lasser Tax Institute, now published by Wiley.

Conference on Wills, Annuities, and Special Gifts, conference report by the National Council of Churches of Christ in the United States of America (December 15-16, 1952).

Charitable trust and private foundation abuses and investigations (1950-1968) and the Tax Reform Act of 1969: General Explanation Of The Tax Reform Act Of 1969, (H.R. 13270, 91st Congress, Public Law 91-172), Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation at .https://www.jct.gov/publications.html?func=startdown&id=2406. Also see “A Landmark in Charitable Gift Planning: 50th Anniversary of 1969 Tax Reform Act,” Ronald Brown at https://giftplanninghistory.org/2019/09/01/comprehensive-policies-on-charitable-gift-planning-in-america-the-tax-reform-act-of-1969/

Tax Reform Act of 1986 (P.L. 99-514, 100 Stat. 2085): crises over charitable remainder trusts as tax shelters, and “finder’s fees.”  See https://www.congress.gov/bill/99th-congress/house-bill/3838 and “Getting to ‘Yes’ on Tax Reform: What Lessons can Congress Learn from the Tax Reform Act of 1986?,” a hearing before the Senate Finance Committee on February 10, 2015 at https://www.finance.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/98328.pdf  Also see “The Tax Reform Act of 1986 Re-Opens the Window for Abuses,” Ronald Brown at https://giftplanninghistory.org/2019/09/01/the-tax-reform-act-of-1986-re-opens-the-window-for-abuses/

National Committee on Planned Giving founding (1988) and early accomplishments, including ethical guidelines for planned gifts: the CANARAS Convention (1989) and Code (1990), and the Model Standards of Practice for the Charitable Gift Planner (1991). See “A Fledgling National Association Earns its Wings,” Ronald Brown at https://giftplanninghistory.org/2019/09/24/the-first-ethical-standards-for-gift-planners/

Lawsuits seeking triple damages resolved by Charitable Accord, the Philanthropy Protection Act (1995) and Charitable Donation Antitrust Immunity Act (1997): Joseph O. Bull, “Forgotten, But Not Gone: The Philanthropy Protection Act of 1995,” presented at the ACGA Conference in 2014. Also the webinar “The History of ACGA is the History of Gift Planning in America” by Ron Brown, ACGA Conference 2020.

James Baldwin on American history: “10 James Baldwin Books to Read Today” at https://www.oprahmag.com/entertainment/books/a26012817/best-james-baldwin-books/ and Begin Again: James Baldwin’s America and Its Urgent Lessons for Our Own by Eddie Glaude, Jr. (New York: Penguin Random House, 2020). Also the film documentary I Am Not Your Negro (2016) directed by Raoul Peck.

For a much longer bibliography see my website at https://wp.me/Pb878a-a3.


More about America is a Given Place:

Brief preview clip: https://wp.me/pb878a-fH

Practical benefits from watching: https://wp.me/pb878a-gH

Praise for the webinar: https://wp.me/pb878a-fs

Support by the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners: https://wp.me/pb878a-gw

Ron Brown’s speaker bio and promotional piece for your website: https://wp.me/pb878a-gV

Summary outline of webinar topics: https://wp.me/pb878a-gf

 

Preview America is a Given Place

For more information and to schedule the webinar: https://wp.me/pb878a-eQ


More about America is a Given Place:

Practical benefits from watching: https://wp.me/pb878a-gH

Praise for the webinar: https://wp.me/pb878a-fs

Support by the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners: https://wp.me/pb878a-gw

Ron Brown’s speaker bio and promotional piece for your website: https://wp.me/pb878a-gV

Summary outline of webinar topics: https://wp.me/pb878a-gf

Selected sources: https://wp.me/pb878a-go

“Donation Mania” in 1786!

Dr. Benjamin Rush was a pioneer in the care of mentally ill patients. He wrote a satire in 1786 entitled “On the Different Species of Manias” in the brand-new United States of America, including “Donation Mania,” which afflicted those who “impoverished their families, by extravagant contributions to public undertakings, or who neglect their relations at their death, by bequeathing their estates to hospitals, colleges, and churches.”

You can learn a lot from reading satire! Rush wrote this with tongue in cheek, but his readers must have known people in 18th century America who seemed to have “donation mania.”

God bless them!

Webinar: Philadelphia’s Leadership in American Charitable Gift Planning

Benjamin Franklin provided innovative fundraising ideas for Pennsylvania Hospital, founded in 1751

Presented by Ron Brown on June 18, 12:00-1:00 pm

Join us for an eye-opening survey of gift planning in America, including important roles played by Philadelphia. Topics include:

  1. When did charitable bequests, trusts & annuities first appear in America? We begin at the beginning, with planned gifts by Mayflower Pilgrims, John Harvard, and other early colonists. That is the only way to understand what comes later.
  2. Philadelphia provided leadership in American gift planning in many ways. Ben Franklin invented “crowd funding” and other innovations for The Pennsylvania Hospital; Stephen Girard’s bequest changed national policy on charitable trusts; and Philadelphia actuary George Huggins introduced data-based decision-making into American philanthropy.
  3. A national class-action lawsuit threatened 1,900 U.S. nonprofits with triple damages over gift annuities.  Why the Philanthropy Protection Act of 1995 remains important for gift planners.
  4. Tax reforms in 1969 and 1986 led to a great wave of life-income gifts but opened the door to self-dealing abuses. A new national association of charitable gift planners provided ethical standards, advanced professional training, and networking.

Registration is $15 for non-members of the Planned Giving Council of Greater Philadelphia:  https://pgcgp.org/event-3585700

True Stories: Charitable Gift Planning from the Pilgrims to Tomorrow’s Gifts

Charitable bequests were a financial lifeline for The Pennsylvania Hospital, founded in 1751 by Benjamin Franklin and Dr. Thomas Bond of Philadelphia.

A presentation for the Planned Giving Council of Greater Philadelphia                  (March 27, 2020)

Few people have heard the story of gift planning quite this way.  See planned gifts by a Mayflower Pilgrim, President George Washington, and the founders of The Pennsylvania Hospital; understand why most states and the U.S. Supreme Court once found charitable trusts to be illegal, and why they changed their minds; how John Trumbull’s paintings of the War for American Independence were saved through a gift annuity; why best practices from the 1920s remain core values of gift planning; why Tax Reform Acts in 1969 and 1986 led to a national association of charitable gift planners; and how rapidly-changing demographics of wealth and age will shape American gift planning for decades to come.

Participants will understand the foundational gifts, best practices, legislation, and court decisions that shape gift planning today; unlock a treasure chest of useful, illuminating, and entertaining donor stories; and gain a powerful perspective on the roots of current events in gift planning.

Register at: https://pgcgp.org/event-3585693

 

Summary and Ron Brown bio for your website

America is a Given Place: A Brief History of Charitable Gift Planning

Where can you turn for knowledge of events that shape gift planning today?

In this entertaining new webinar you will learn the foundations of gift planning in the U.S. by seeing major donors and events, appreciating innovations, and reliving landmark debates and resulting legislation.

What will you gain by participating in America is a Given Place? Knowing the history of charitable gift planning is quite useful, even indispensable, for people who encourage or advise donors. Here is a sampler of your benefits:

  • You will understand the principles behind laws, regulations and practices, so you can explain why things work the way they do
  • History informs your marketing. Stories of realized bequests and trusts are historical narratives!
  • Good stories provide you with insights into how donors, planners, & policymakers saw themselves and their mission, and inspire you to connect more deeply
  • Historical trends in mortality and investment returns play a fundamental role in your gift design and tax calculations
  • History enables you to know yourself and your important role in America’s highly evolved system of philanthropy

The bottom line is: you will be a better-informed, more effective gift planner.

About Ron Brown

America is a Given Place is based on my 40 years as a charitable gift planner, including 15 years as director of gift planning at Princeton University, my alma mater. I served on the boards of the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners and the American Council on Gift Annuities. In 2019 the Philanthropic Planning Group of Greater New York selected me for a distinguished service award.

I was trained as a professional historian 30 years ago and have devoted thousands of hours to scholarly research and writing. I published some of the results in A History of Charitable Gift Planning (Amazon 2017) and add content from time to time at http://www.giftplanninghistory.org.

———-

More about America is a Given Place:

Brief preview clip: https://wp.me/pb878a-fH

Practical benefits from watching: https://wp.me/pb878a-gH

Praise for the webinar: https://wp.me/pb878a-fs

Support by the National Association of Charitable Gift Planners: https://wp.me/pb878a-gw

Summary outline of webinar topics: https://wp.me/pb878a-gf

Selected sources: https://wp.me/pb878a-go

Battle of Bunkers Hill

The History of ACGA is the History of Gift Planning in America

Battle of Bunkers HillAttend the ACGA Conference in Atlanta on April 20-22 to understand the historical foundations of charitable gift planning:

  1. When did charitable trusts & annuities first appear in America?  (Hint: earlier than you may realize!)
  2. What does it mean to say that modern charitable gift planning was born at the ACGA Conference in 1927?  (Managing risk takes science & art.)
  3. Why does the Philanthropy Protection Act of 1995 matter for gift planners today?  (We all know the answer to this.  Don’t we?)
  4. What has the American Council on Gift Annuities accomplished?  (Donors, beneficiaries, professional service providers, nonprofit organizations, & the American people have benefitted.  Big time.)

This may be a once-in-a-lifetime learning opportunity!  Register at:  https://www.acga-web.org/conference-registration